A paid trial scorecard for hiring household or office staff

Choose one representative task

Start with the main outcome of the role. A cook might prepare a normal meal, a housekeeper might clean an agreed area, and an office helper might explain and complete a small supervised routine. The task should be realistic and limited enough to observe carefully. Do not add several unrelated duties just because a candidate is present. If the job requires a specialist qualification, a practical trial does not replace checking that requirement or arranging appropriate professional assessment.

Agree the terms before the trial starts

Explain the task, location, duration, equipment, supervision and payment in advance. State which responsibilities are excluded and who can answer questions. Make sure the candidate understands any access or travel arrangements for your Islamabad or Rawalpindi property. Avoid a situation where the person expects an interview and is suddenly asked to cover a working shift. If the scope changes, discuss it before the extra work begins. Keep a simple written record of what both sides agreed.

Score a few observable criteria

Use four headings: following the brief, quality of the task, organisation and communication. For each, write what you actually observed and any instruction that was missing. A short scale such as needs support, meets the brief and exceeds the brief can help structure discussion, but should not conceal uncertainty. Judge the work against the agreed task rather than an unstated personal preference. Use the same core criteria when comparing candidates and allow for familiarisation with equipment they have not used before.

Give feedback and decide the next step

Discuss the result promptly, pay the agreed amount and explain whether more information is needed. Distinguish a trainable gap from an essential duty the candidate cannot yet demonstrate. Ask for references with permission and confirm completed checks with Hire Staff Islamabad before making the final decision. If you proceed, turn the agreed trial scope into the full role description, adding hours, wages, time off and placement terms. If you decline, keep feedback factual and limited to the job requirements.

A common question

Continue planning your hire